Active

$1,700,000

2134 Asbury Avenue, Evanston, IL 60201
6 Beds4 Baths0 sqft7 days
2134 Asbury Avenue·Evanston, IL 60201
6Bedrooms
4Bathrooms
0Sq Ft
1890Year Built
About This Home

Own a piece of Evanston History Now this beautifully fully restored single-family vintage farm house with 9 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and a separate two-story coach house, all situated on a double lot at the corner of Asbury and Leonard across from Ingram Park. The owner has thoughtfully restored the property, creating a spacious and versatile home with plenty of room for comfortable living, multigenerational use, or rental opportunities. The main home features an open-concept main floor with two bedrooms and a full bathroom. The second floor offers four additional bedrooms and two full bathrooms, while the basement includes three bedrooms a full bathroom, laundry, a large open kitchenette living area along with separate entrances front and rear of the home. The main home offers two separate laundry areas for convenience and functionality; for a large household or potential rental use with a live-in separate living area. The separate two-story coach house features one bedroom, 1 1/2 baths, and a separate laundry area. The second floor offers a generous living area with a balcony. This space offers excellent flexibility as a private space for extended family, guests, a home office, or a separate rental opportunity with potential for additional income. The 1859 horse stable barn was one of Evanstons first structures. Rumor has it 2134 Asbury was once a dairy farm, and delivered milk to the surrounding area. The original property had a barn once used for one of the first Express companies in early Evanston history. During prohibition, the owners had a still in the barn and delivered alcohol with the milk via horse drawn taxi services. This structure has been restored with unique features and workmanship, keeping period correct restoration. All equipped with separate electrical service, copper plumbing, new gas, water, and sewer services. Along with the historic barn on the rear of the property is an additional 1 1/2 car garage. The property has been completely updated with city services with both copper water supply and sewer lines. The entire property has new plumbing with high efficiency on-demand water heaters, electrical updated to state and city building codes, gas supplies, all new mechanicals with hvac mechanicals and ductwork. All new roofing on all buildings. This property offers substantial space both inside and out. With its extensive restoration, generous bedroom count, coach house, rear garage, and flexible layout, this home presents an excellent opportunity for an owner-occupant, multigenerational household, or investor looking to maximize the property's rental potential. The property is currently in the final restoration phase with options available to the new owner. It has the option of an additional adu in the basement area built to suit your desires.

MLS# 12738238Listed November 4, 2026ResidentialFarmhouse
Property Details

Beds & Baths

Total Bedrooms6
Total Bathrooms4
Full Baths4
Half Baths0
Total Rooms12

Size & Structure

Living Area0 sqft
Garage Spaces2
Year Built1890
Lot Size50 X 140

Location

CountyCook
TownshipNiles
Zip Code60201

Financial

List Price$1,700,000
Annual Taxes (2025)$15,765
Monthly Tax Est.$1,314
Parcel #10124250100000
Interior Features

Appliances

Double OvenRangeDishwasherWasherDryerStainless Steel Appliance(s)Wine RefrigeratorOvenGas Cooktop

Flooring

HardwoodCarpet

Heating

Sep Heating Systems - 2+

Cooling

Central Air

Basement

FinishedExterior EntryFull

Laundry

Main LevelIn UnitMultiple Locations
Exterior & Lot

Construction

Frame

Patio & Porch

Patio

Lot Features

Corner LotLandscaped
Utilities & Parking

Sewer

Public Sewer

Water Source

Lake MichiganPublic

Electric

200+ Amp Service150 Amp Service

Parking

Off AlleyYesGarage OwnedDetachedGarage
HOA & Community

HOA Includes

None

Community Features

ParkCurbsSidewalksStreet LightsStreet Paved
Schools
Elementary
Orrington Elementary School
District: 65
Middle School
Haven Middle School
District: 65
High School
Evanston Twp High School
District: 202
Tax & Financial
Annual Taxes
$15,765
Tax Year 2025
Monthly Tax Est.
$1,314
per month
Property Location

2134 Asbury Avenue, Evanston, IL 60201 — Cook County

$1,700,000
2134 Asbury Avenue
6 bd4 ba0 sqft
VL
Vittoria Logli
Top Glenview Agent

IL License 475.178467 · (847) 810-8438

Quick Facts
7 days on market
2-car garage
50 X 140
$15,765/yr taxes
$10,248
estimated monthly payment
Principal & Interest
$8,934/mo
Property Tax
$1,314/mo
$1,700,000
20% — $340,000
3%50%
6.875%
3%12%
Loan Amount
$1,360,000
Down Payment
$340,000

* Estimated payment only. Actual rates, taxes, and insurance may vary. Contact a lender for a personalized quote.

Listed by
Baird & Warner
Agent: Sheila Doyle
Similar Homes

You May Also Like

Keep Exploring

Find Your Perfect Home

Browse available listings in Evanston and across the North Shore.

Also popular on the North Shore

REALTOR® Logo
Equal Housing Opportunity LogoEqual Housing Opportunity

Listing Courtesy: MRED as distributed by MLS GRID | @properties Christie's International Real Estate

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy.

© 2026 MLS GRID. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use.