Closed

$1,579,000

1812 Asbury Avenue, Evanston, IL 60201
5 Beds5 Baths0 sqft2 days
1812 Asbury Avenue·Evanston, IL 60201
5Bedrooms
5Bathrooms
0Sq Ft
1874Year Built
About This Home

For the first time in 40 years, this historic mansion is ready to change hands. Originally constructed in 1874 for a former member of Congress and the first president of the Evanston Board of Trustees, the Charles J. Gilbert House is celebrating its 150th birthday this year. A Second Empire Victorian with Italianate features and mansard roof that were de rigueur for prominent estates of the time, the subsequent addition of a portico with Corinthian columns was inspired by the 1893 Columbian Exposition in Chicago, further punctuating the incredible curb appeal and prominence of one of Evanston's most important historical homes. Approaching the entrance, you are greeted by a gracious brick patio spanning the full width of the home with beautifully carved double entry doors. Once inside, the stunning original woodwork of the central hallway and staircase balustrades will take your breath away. Two double parlors are accessed on either side, leading the visitor to stately living and entertaining rooms; each with 9 foot tall windows welcoming the light and soaring ceilings with hand-carved plaster medallions crowning the chandeliers. There are three imported Italian marble fireplaces on the first level, with a total of eight throughout the home; of which two are fired by gas; one by wood with the remaining five decorative. A separate formal dining room is bathed in light and grace and the all-stainless kitchen spills out onto a breakfast area overlooking an expansive and beautifully landscaped yard with mature trees. Moving up, the second floor hosts four large bedrooms with generous closets, including a primary suite with large adjoining reception area, a second full bath, laundry room, home office, and a grand 40x12 covered porch providing a secluded outdoor oasis overlooking the well manicured foregrounds along Asbury Ave. The third floor contains a large one bedroom in-law apartment with its own living, dining and kitchen; a large recreation room that in bygone times served as a ballroom; and a game room that has hosted many a billiards match. A second two bedroom in-law apartment with kitchen, full bath, laundry and living quarters along with the mechanicals and storage for the house can be found belowdecks in the partially above grade basement. In all, there's approximately 7,500 square feet of mostly finished living space on a 28,000 square foot (115x244) lot within walking distance to downtown Evanston's abundant shopping, dining and entertainment options; commuter Metra and Chicago "el" train lines; Northwestern University and Lake Michigan.

MLS# 12258428Listed January 23, 2025ResidentialVictorian
Property Details

Beds & Baths

Total Bedrooms5
Total Bathrooms5
Full Baths4
Half Baths1
Total Rooms17

Size & Structure

Living Area0 sqft
Garage Spaces2
Fireplaces8
Year Built1874
Lot Size0.630 acres

Location

CountyCook
TownshipEvanston
Zip Code60201

Financial

List Price$1,579,000
Annual Taxes (2023)$38,500
Monthly Tax Est.$3,208
Parcel #10132190160000
Interior Features

Appliances

RangeMicrowaveDishwasherRefrigeratorWasherDryerDisposalStainless Steel Appliance(s)OvenRange Hood

Flooring

Hardwood

Heating

Natural GasRadiator(s)

Cooling

PartialSmall Duct High VelocityGas

Basement

Partially FinishedFull

Laundry

Upper LevelIn UnitMultiple Locations

Fireplace

Gas LogGas Starter
Exterior & Lot

Construction

Plaster

Patio & Porch

DeckPatioPorch
Utilities & Parking

Sewer

Public SewerStorm Sewer

Water Source

Lake MichiganPublic

Electric

Circuit Breakers

Parking

Garage Door OpenerOn SiteGarage OwnedDetachedGarage
Schools
Elementary
Orrington Elementary School
District: 65
Middle School
Haven Middle School
District: 65
High School
Evanston Twp High School
District: 202
Tax & Financial
Annual Taxes
$38,500
Tax Year 2023
Monthly Tax Est.
$3,208
per month
Property Location

1812 Asbury Avenue, Evanston, IL 60201 — Cook County

$1,579,000
1812 Asbury Avenue
5 bd5 ba0 sqft
VL
Vittoria Logli
Top Glenview Agent

IL License 475.178467 · (847) 810-8438

Quick Facts
2 days on market
2-car garage
8 fireplaces
0.630 acres
$38,500/yr taxes
$11,507
estimated monthly payment
Principal & Interest
$8,298/mo
Property Tax
$3,208/mo
$1,579,000
20% — $315,800
3%50%
6.875%
3%12%
Loan Amount
$1,263,200
Down Payment
$315,800

* Estimated payment only. Actual rates, taxes, and insurance may vary. Contact a lender for a personalized quote.

Listed by
Pyne Properties, LLC
Agent: Daniel Pyne
Similar Homes

You May Also Like

Keep Exploring

Find Your Perfect Home

Browse available listings in Evanston and across the North Shore.

Also popular on the North Shore

REALTOR® Logo
Equal Housing Opportunity LogoEqual Housing Opportunity

Listing Courtesy: MRED as distributed by MLS GRID | @properties Christie's International Real Estate

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy.

© 2026 MLS GRID. All rights reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use.